
MESSAGES THAT LAND – Monday 2nd November
Nobody wants to be the Fall Guy
Nobody wants to be the Fall Guy
There’s something wonderfully odd about Bonfire Night.
We build a man out of old clothes, sit him on top of a bonfire with a pole up his undercroft and then spend the evening setting fire to things around him.
Poor Guy.
And, to be fair, nobody really wants to be the fall guy in business either. Especially in a creative team. Because the fall guy is often the one who has to ask the awkward question.
“Do we actually need this?”
“Who is this for?”
“What are we trying to make happen?”
“Are we trying to say too much?”
“Is video really the answer?”
And suddenly, while everyone else is getting excited about the idea, the fall “guy” is the one standing there looking like the fun sponge. It’s a tricky role to play but…
Every team needs one
Somebody has to do it. Because ideas gather momentum very quickly and can go off at unhelpful tangents or unnecessary detail before it’s known who it’s talking to or the specific outcomes required. Someone says, “We should do a podcast.” Five minutes later somebody is talking about episode length. “We need some video.” Suddenly there is a filming date in the diary. “We should get loads of clips while we’re there.” Now we are discussing whether we need twelve, twenty or thirty.
Don’t get me wrong. These are all perfectly sensible conversations. Apart from one small problem. Nobody has actually stopped to ask what any of it is supposed to achieve. That is where the fall guy earns their keep. Not by killing the idea but by testing it. Who needs to hear this? What do we want them to understand? Why should they care? What do we want to happen afterwards? And does the format we have chosen actually help us get there? Those questions can feel like somebody applying the brakes. Often they are actually stopping you driving straight into a hedge.
Without one, the wrong thing can become very polished
This is the dangerous bit. A bad idea does not necessarily look bad while you are making it. It can have a lovely camera move, beautifully edited, animated graphics, captions, music and a very impressive thumbnail. Yet could still be solving the wrong problem. Because if nobody challenged the idea at the beginning, a team can spend a lot of time and money making the wrong thing look amazing.
Trouble is, eventually, somebody asks the question nobody wanted to ask at the start. “Did it actually work?”. At which point everyone starts looking for the real fall guy. That’s when it get REALLY awkward.
The person asking awkward questions needs backing
There is another side to this. You cannot tell people you want honest thinking and then make life difficult for them every time they challenge something. If someone is going to play this role, they need support. They need to know that saying: “I’m not sure this is the right format” does not make them negative. Asking: “What is the actual objective?” does not make them difficult. And saying: “I think we should make less” does not mean they lack ambition.
So who is your Guy?
This Bonfire Night, spare a thought for the person in your team who is prepared to stand slightly outside the excitement and ask whether the whole thing really needs lighting in the first place. They might look like the fun sponge. They might feel like the fall guy. But they may also be the person protecting the budget, the audience and the idea. And if nobody in the room feels able to play that role, that is probably worth noticing. Because good content does not start with pressing record.
It starts with a better conversation.
Yes, asking the awkward question now may make you unpopular for five minutes. But keeping things on track could be exactly what turns a damp squib into a bonfire of bold ideas.
